Short Answer
In April 2020, Queen Alenym of Taygeta announced that the Federation itself — not some infiltrator — was the ultimate controller of Earth. Within days, the Taygetans, the Urmah, and the Engans discovered they had been quietly excluded from Federation council meetings and chose to withdraw. From that rupture grew the Alcyone Council's independent stance: a coalition of Pleiadian races, allied with the Urmah Feline Federation, that openly challenges Federation policy on Earth. But despite this opposition, they have not "liberated" the planet, and they say they cannot — for reasons that are structural, political, military, and even philosophical. The material presents a picture of genuine resistance operating within severe constraints, not a force that is choosing inaction.
The Rupture: April 2020
Transcript 086 records the pivotal moment. Alenym opens with: "This is very painful to say. And I only found out four days ago. And I've been quite upset." What she had discovered was that the Federation — the Andromedans, Arcturians, Sirians, Pleiadians, and all the rest — were not merely tolerating Earth's suffering. They were the architects of it. Not because they were infiltrated by some external evil, but because guiding a young civilisation through hardship was, in their view, how interstellar races are born. Swaruu 9 frames it starkly: "The good news is that the Federation or conglomerate of 'positive' races has sent aid to Earth. The bad news is that you are that aid."
The immediate political consequence was expulsion. Alenym arrived at the Saturday council meeting in the Viera and was told it was cancelled — a lie. Urmah King Ruhr arrived and was told his presence "is no longer necessary." The Engans received similar treatment. Nai'Shara notes: "That is why we have been branded as scandalous." Aneeka adds: "That's why they limit us to keyboard. They don't give us nor will they give us audio much less video."
Alenym's response was defiance: "I expose and accuse the Federation of this abuse, no matter how valid their reasons might be." But Swaruu 9 insisted on nuance even in this moment of crisis: "The Federation is not 'Bad' or 'Good'. It just is."
Alenym's Role: From Step-Down to Queen to Rebel
Mari's account of Alenym's history in S-237 provides the political backstory. Taygeta had been without a monarch for a long time when the Cabal of Earth attempted to install a puppet queen with strong Federation political connections. The Taygetan High Council saw the danger and elevated Alenym — who had lived on Earth as a step-down for years and understood firsthand what was happening on the surface.
Once in power, Alenym reversed the propaganda and mind control that had been softening Taygeta for infiltration. She was then appointed by the Alcyone Council as their ambassador and representative to the Federation. From that position, she systematically shared what she knew about Earth with other Pleiadian races, "finally winning over many allies, which include all the members of the Alcyone Council, which means all the Pleiades star system members" (S-237).
She also signed alliance and cooperation treaties with the Urmah Feline Federation, who already harboured deep suspicions about the Federation's management of Earth. The result was a growing coalition of races openly questioning Federation policy — something that had not happened before.
But it came at a cost. Alenym stopped attending Federation meetings in person, fearing for her safety. She eventually confined herself to the Toleka. Mari reports in S-246 that there is forensic evidence of an assassination attempt against Alenym originating from the Saturn Federation level. By the time of the S-237 transcript in mid-2024, Alenym was recovering in a medical pod and had not yet emerged.
The Alcyone Council: What It Is and What It Represents
The Alcyone Council is the political body that governs the M45 Pleiades star cluster. Aneeka explains in transcript 149 that it "represents all civilizations within the Pleiades star system M45" and "does have a lot of weight in the decisions and the politics inside the Federation." Athena clarifies in 408 that it functions much like the Andromeda Council or the Sphere Alliance — officially independent bodies that nonetheless form part of the larger Federation structure.
After Alenym's influence, the Alcyone Council moved toward open disagreement with the Federation on Earth policy. Aneeka reports in 149 that a meeting between the Alcyone Council and the Federation "ended up in an almost disaster as they are fragmented now and almost operating as two different Councils. Alcyone and Federation do not agree with what is going on on Earth."
Arishah of the Urmah confirms this shift in S-118: "The treachery we see occurring with Earth has alerted us a lot more nowadays, especially after the Alcyone Council decided to agree with us in this perspective. We are happy not to be the only ones with a different opinion about what is happening on Earth." This is significant because the Urmah had long been sceptical of the Federation, but previously had been largely alone in that position.
The Urmah Alliance: Cats Who Don't Follow Rules
The Urmah Feline Federation is the Alcyone Council's most powerful ally in this dispute. As Athena explains in 377, the Urmah "represent the Council of Avyon, which is the Feline Galactic Confederation, which is so big that it strongly rivals the Galactic Federation itself."
The Urmah relationship with the Federation is fundamentally different from the Taygetan one. Arishah describes it in S-118: "We have never fully trusted the Federation, and we have never conformed to their rules. We have always gone our own way." When the Federation sends craft to monitor Urmah activity, "we simply proceed with our business disregarding their presence, as if they weren't even there" (S-198).
The Urmah have also taken direct action. In 2023, they destroyed a Pfizer vaccine plant using their ship's tractor beam, an act disguised by media as a rare tornado (377). The Federation was "very angry" because it violated the Prime Directive. Athena's commentary: "But since when can you give a Cat orders? Even more so if they are many cats of 300 kilos with armor and spaceships."
By September 2024, Yazhi reports that the Taygetan fleet is expanding: "More ships arriving much to their [Federation] displeasure. That's what Alcyone class ships are for, to counter-intimidate. And yes, we accept that we are getting very militarized, but it's either that or get eaten" (443).
Why They Can't Simply "Liberate" Earth
Given this opposition, the obvious question is: why don't they act? The material offers several interlocking reasons.
Liberation causes worse problems than it solves. Alenym's analysis in 265 is the most thorough treatment. Sending a liberating fleet "will make it much worse and in the short term, besides extending the problem to those who have sent such a 'liberating' fleet." The liberating civilisation would be perceived as invading and imposing its values. This would cause "interaction problems among the other races," decreased trust, ostracism, and even the accusation of tyranny. As Alenym puts it: "If a larger body, such as the United Federation of Planets, liberates any world, it will lead to another big problem, that such a super political body has acquired too much power... inviting tyranny on a large scale. And that is something we may be facing precisely today."
The population would not change. Even if the oppressors were removed, "its inhabitants will not have changed their own mentality that made them compatible to that situation, inexorably repeating itself later" (265). The Urmah echo this in S-118: Arishah notes that removing dark entities is futile if "it is humanity itself that forms and will form them again." Civilisation resets have been done before — Arishah says Alfrata's "liberation" was "nothing but pantomime, a reset... They erased their past to start over."
The Federation's inaccessible structure prevents confrontation. Even races who oppose Federation policy have no one to confront. Aneeka describes in 408 how the Saturn-level Federation sends anonymous orders with validation codes and no return address. Going to Saturn physically means entering "a massive traffic area with large biosphere ships of many races" — finding the decision-makers is like "going to Los Angeles in California, good luck finding someone who doesn't want to be found there." The system is deliberately structured so that "to remove them from office you must first know who they are, and that is what they circumvent with anonymity."
The Federation controls the narrative for other races. Mari explains in S-237 that most star races "simply believe the official Galactic Federation narrative" because they are under the same kind of perception management that controls humans on Earth, only at a larger scale. When Alenym tried to awaken other races, the Federation responded with propaganda depicting the Alcyone Council as rebellious and even evil. "On at least one popular New Age platform on Earth, the Alcyone Council is seen and depicted as an evil organization working against the Federation of love and light" (S-246).
The soul-will argument is hard to defeat. The Urmah's Arishah admits in S-198 that "the only thing that is keeping us at bay is the weak Federation argument that Earth is as it is because its inhabitants want it to be so, all for the learning experience. As long as that stands, we cannot and will not intervene." The Federation's formal conferences (S-233) present three core arguments: souls enter Earth by choice for spiritual expansion, Earth's destructive mentality must be contained to protect other civilisations, and direct contact would collapse the Matrix entirely. While the opposition disagrees with these arguments, they cannot definitively disprove them.
The Gori'el Conferences: Federation Explains Itself
By mid-2024, the growing dissent forced the Federation to act. Mari reports in S-233 that the local Federation began offering conferences to explain why Earth must be kept as it is, held twice monthly in the Viera. The first was on 29 June 2024. Captain Gori'el of the Taygetan dreadnought Alcyone attended as the Taygetan representative.
Mari notes the Federation separated attendees by genetic family, preventing cross-racial organisation — a tactic she describes as "a separation strategy to limit interaction and to prevent the races from organizing." Only 34 people attended the Lyrian-human room, mostly Alfratan Centauri with a small Antarian group and the five Taygetans. No Etorthans or Andromedans were present.
The three points the Federation presented were: souls choose Earth freely for spiritual growth through hardship; Earth's destructive mentality must be isolated from the galactic community; and direct contact would collapse the Matrix, leaving no realm for souls seeking that level of challenge. Mari counters that suffering can cause stagnation rather than growth, and that advanced souls need peace, not hardship, to evolve.
What the Alcyone Council Is Actually Doing
Despite the constraints, the opposition is not passive. The material describes several active strategies.
Alenym and later Mari organised counter-meetings — alternative conferences away from Federation headquarters where races could discuss Earth without Federation framing. The Andromedan representative who confronted Mari in S-246 specifically accused her of "organizing meetings about the situation of Earth which are meant to counter the meetings the Galactic Federation has kindly set up."
The Taygetans and Urmah maintain an intelligence-gathering operation (CIC) that monitors Federation activity and shares findings with allied races. Transcript 423 describes an Alcyone spacecraft Internet project designed to "flood media with ETs" and guide perception of reality through online engagement — essentially a counter-propaganda operation.
The military buildup is itself a form of resistance. The arrival of Alcyone-class dreadnoughts sends a political message. As Yazhi says: the ships are there "to counter-intimidate" (443). The Urmah flagship Avyon One flies in tandem with the Taygetan vessels.
And the information-sharing operation through Gosia, Robert, and Mari's YouTube channel is characterised as the most important action of all. Mari states in S-237 that "without Queen Alenym, no one here would be allowed to write and share on your media, and we would be silenced for good." The entire disclosure project is presented as the Alcyone Council's primary strategy: awakening both human and stellar consciousness simultaneously.
Transcript Reference Table
| # | Title | Speaker(s) | Key Content |
|---|-------|-----------|-------------|
| 086 | Truth About Federation | Swaruu 9, Alenym, Aneeka, Nai'Shara, Gosia | Pivotal revelation — Federation IS the controller — Taygeta/Urmah/Engan excluded and withdraw — cosmic school model — "Federation is not Bad or Good, it just is" |
| 149 | Questions for Aneeka — Live Q&A | Aneeka | Alcyone Council vs Federation "almost operating as two different Councils" — Alcyone strong weight in Federation politics — Federation multi-layered |
| 265 | Exopolitics with Alenym — Liberation Does Not Work | Alenym, Gosia, Robert | Liberation causes worse problems — refugees export values — exopolitical ostracism — humanity must solve own problems — Federation jurisdiction lost in upper bureaucracy |
| 377 | Pfizer Factory Tornado | Athena, Gosia, Robert | Urmah tractor beam attack on Pfizer plant — bypassed Prime Directive — Federation angry but can't control cats — Avyon Council rivals Federation in size |
| 408 | Federation and Saturn — Leaders Impossible to Find | Aneeka | Saturn Federation anonymous — validation code orders with no sender — system broken and pyramidal — same structure as Earth's dark government |
| 443 | Chatting with Yazhi — September 2024 | Yazhi, Robert | Fleet militarisation — Alcyone class ships to counter-intimidate — "either that or get eaten" — Alenym still in medical pod |
| S-118 | Urmah Interview — Arishah Part 2 | Mari, Arishah | Urmah always knew Federation bred corruption — Alcyone Council now agrees — Taygetans blinded by propaganda until Alenym — Federation manifesting Earth's nightmares through manipulation — civilisation resets are shams |
| S-233 | Gori'el Report — Why Earth Must Be Kept As It Is | Mari | Federation conferences explaining non-intervention — three arguments (soul choice, containment, Matrix collapse) — attendees separated by race to prevent organising |
| S-237 | Queen Alenym — Taygetan Princess Queen | Mari | Cabal attempted puppet queen in Taygeta — Alenym crowned to prevent it — lived on Earth as step-down — spread awareness through Alcyone Council — signed Urmah alliance treaties — assassination attempt — most star races under Federation propaganda spell |
| S-246 | Diplomatic Incident — August 2024 | Mari | Andromedan representative demands Mari stop criticising Federation — accuses her of instigating rebellion — Mari accuses Federation of assassination attempt on Alenym from Saturn level |